CARNOUSTIE, SCOTLAND | Point out Carnoustie, and the primary affiliation most golfers have with this village on the mouth of the Barry Burn is as an Open Championship venue so robust it got here to be known as Automobile-nasty.
The Open is staged on the Championship Course, one in every of three 18-hole layouts on a desolate North Sea hyperlinks that lies a mere 14 miles north of St. Andrews because the seagull flies and has hosted eight of these tournaments thus far. Invariably, it produces nice winners. Tommy Armour prevailed within the 1931 version and Ben Hogan in 1953. Gary Participant and Tom Watson had been victors right here as effectively, in 1968 and 1975, respectively. And Pádraig Harrington got here out on prime in 2007.
However Carnoustie is simply as well-known for derailing the quests of gamers to change into the Champion Golfer of the 12 months, with nobody ever crashing fairly as spectacularly as Frenchman Jean van de Velde in 1999 when he misplaced a three-stroke lead on the ultimate gap of regulation play – after which misplaced a playoff to Paul Lawrie.
“These boys grew to become among the many finest golfers in America for a few years. They had been the equal of the Mannings in skilled soccer within the States. And from 1898 to 1936, a Smith was a favourite within the U.S. Open.” — David Mackesey, Carnoustie Golf Membership historian
What is far much less identified, nonetheless, is the outsized position this burg of 4,000 residents on the flip of the twentieth century performed within the improvement of golf in America. That’s when greater than 200 of its native sons traveled to the States to work on the golf and nation golf equipment that had been opening all through that land and train People methods to play and perceive the royal and historical recreation. Thanks in no small half to their enthusiastic and efficient tutelage – and their willingness to endure lengthy separations from their households and mates again dwelling whereas shifting incessantly to totally different jobs all through the U.S. – the game got here to prosper within the New World.
The legacy of the immigrant execs from Carnoustie is a outstanding one. And a single household, led by John Smith and together with his three sons Alex, Willie and Macdonald, stands out for the appreciable contributions it made to golf’s progress and improvement there.
“These boys grew to become among the many finest golfers in America for a few years,” mentioned David Mackesey, the historian for the Carnoustie Golf Membership, which counted all three of them as members. “They had been the equal of the Mannings in skilled soccer within the States. And from 1898 to 1936, a Smith was a favourite within the U.S. Open.”
The brothers had been additionally a favourite on the prime golf equipment within the nation that had been seeking to meet their members’ sudden and really passionate curiosity in golf and assist educate them concerning the recreation.
John Smith was born in 1851, and like his father earlier than him toiled for a time within the Dundee jute mills. Jute is a pure fiber that was imported from India and used to make burlap and wire amongst different merchandise. And people factories had been horrid locations, stuffed with the deafening rattle of spinning and carding machines and air so dusty that it took a employee’s breath away. Equally terrible was the stench from the rancid whale oil that was used to melt the fabric.
Happily, Smith discovered a method out when he moved the household to close by Carnoustie, his spouse Joann’s dwelling village, to change into the keeper of the greens on its hyperlinks.
Through the years, Joann gave start to 10 kids, however solely 5 survived infancy. In time, every of these youngsters made their livings as golf professionals in North America, with Alex, Willie and Macdonald having the best successes.
As gamers, the trio captured three U.S. Opens in addition to a number of Western and Metropolitan opens, which had been thought-about main championships in these days. They gained tournaments on the nascent skilled circuit that will change into the PGA Tour, too, and had been contenders within the Open Championship.
Their presence in these occasions, in addition to that of different abroad professionals, stirred curiosity within the recreation and lent credibility to the earliest championships in America by elevating the extent of play and high quality of the fields in what was nonetheless a {golfing} backwater.
The Smith brothers additionally held jobs on the most prestigious golf equipment on the continent, amongst them Shinnecock Hills, Midlothian and Oakmont, and in locales as far ranging as California, Michigan and Florida. They taught their members methods to swing the golf equipment they made and repaired, and defined the principles of golf.
With these and different actions, they unfold the gospel of golf all through North America, introducing tons of of newcomers to the game as in addition they educated among the finest ever to play the sport. Akin to Jerome Travers, who captured 4 U.S. Amateurs; Jack Neville, a five-time California state novice winner who co-designed the Pebble Seashore Golf Hyperlinks; Marion Hollins, who captured the U.S. Ladies’s Beginner title in 1921 earlier than serving to Alister MacKenzie create the course on the Cypress Level Membership; and Glenna Collett Vare, whose enjoying document was so robust that she got here to be often called the feminine Bobby Jones.
Willie Smith is even credited with virtually singlehandedly nurturing the game in Mexico at the same time as that nation – and the Mexico Metropolis Nation Membership for which he labored as the pinnacle golf skilled – was racked by struggle throughout its tumultuous revolution.
Golf has been performed on the hyperlinks of Carnoustie for the reason that 1500s, and data point out that the Championship Course comprised solely 10 holes when it was in-built 1842 by Allan Robertson, a St. Andrean who’s considered the sport’s first golf skilled. Aiding him was his younger apprentice, Tom Morris. 1 / 4 century later, Morris, who by that time had began to be known as Outdated Tom, expanded the format to 18 holes. Maybe its most daunting characteristic was the Barry Burn, a twisting waterway that got here into play at a number of factors throughout the ending holes.
That was the bottom that John Smith tended in his new gig. It was additionally the place his boys discovered the sport. And whereas he actually nurtured their pursuits in golf, it was knowledgeable named Robert Simpson who gave them the equal of a Ph.D. within the enterprise.
Born within the winter of 1862 and finest often called Bob, Simpson grew up simply south of St. Andrews by the historic Elie hyperlinks. He got here from a line of profitable brick masons and weavers. However the Simpsons had been a {golfing} household as effectively, and on the age of 17, Bob began an apprenticeship with the native skilled, George Forrester. In that place, Simpson not solely discovered methods to play the sport but additionally the nuances of membership and ball making in addition to course design and upkeep.
In time, Simpson moved to St. Andrews to work underneath Robert Forgan, whose well-crafted mashies, cleeks and niblicks made him the pre-eminent membership maker on the time – and ultimately the official clubmaker for the Prince of Wales.
Then on the age of 21, Simpson beat out 32 different candidates to change into the golf skilled on the Dalhousie Membership in Carnoustie.
Simpson moved to that city in the summertime of 1883. A couple of months later, his brothers Jack and Archie joined him to assist open and run his store. Each siblings had been robust golfers, with Jack successful the 1884 Open Championship at Prestwick, and Archie coming in second when that match was performed on the Outdated Course in St. Andrews the next 12 months.
Bob Simpson was no slouch with a golf membership, and he completed fourth within the 1885 Open, three pictures behind Archie. However because the skilled at Dalhousie, the place the membership rolls had been populated by landed gentry, jute mill house owners and different denizens of the higher class, he needed to concentrate on his members and their wants. That meant giving classes, enjoying tournaments and exhibitions, and making and repairing their golf golf equipment. Simpson additionally dabbled in course design and within the mid-Nineties helped Outdated Tom tweak the Carnoustie course he had expanded in 1867.
However as a lot as anything, Simpson served as a mentor to younger golfers from Carnoustie, discovering work for them in his store and educating all of them that he knew concerning the recreation and being knowledgeable.
Mackesey says that Simpson employed as many as 30 locals at one time and incessantly wrote letters of advice for his prices once they sought work in different components of the golf world. “And an endorsement from Bob Simpson carried great weight,” Mackesey added. Actually, all of it however assured that the lads can be employed.
A kind of apprentices was the eldest Smith son, Alex, and in time he grew to become the foreman in Simpson’s store.
To many kids in Carnoustie again then, golf was greater than a sport. It was a method out of the jute mills, which employed kids as “half-timers” and promised a lifetime of Dickensian destitution. And lots of of these working in Simpson’s store hoped to seek out and preserve good golf jobs, whether or not within the British Isles or far-off lands like America.
Alex was the primary in his clan to journey to the States, and he did so after answering an commercial the Washington Park Membership in Chicago had positioned looking for 4 clubmakers for the summer season of 1898, with round-trip passage on a crusing ship included. Simply 24 years previous, he was married to Jessie Maiden, a Carnoustie native whose brothers Stewart and Jimmy would additionally change into notable golf professionals in America, and the daddy of a younger daughter named Fannie.
Alex utilized for the place and was accepted together with three St. Andreans, one in every of whom was Fred Herd. They left their homeland in March of that 12 months and returned the next November. And along with impressing their employer with their educating and clubmaking abilities, they demonstrated nice aggressive verve, with Herd successful that 12 months’s U.S. Open, which was held on the Myopia Hunt Membership north of Boston, and Smith ending second. Not far behind, in fifth place, was his brother Willie, who had moved to America two months after Alex to change into the educating skilled at Shinnecock Hills on Lengthy Island.
Alex Smith obtained a heat welcome again in Carnoustie as he additionally discovered that his spouse had given start to a second baby, Margaret. However he was unable to remain for greater than a few months as a result of he wanted to return to the States in January to accompany a gaggle of Washington Park members on a winter golf journey to the Resort del Coronado close to San Diego, California.
Smith hated to depart Carnoustie so rapidly. Nevertheless it helped that his brother Willie had taken a brand new job as the pinnacle skilled on the Midlothian Nation Membership within the Chicago suburbs, not removed from Washington Park, the place Alex can be spending one other summer season.
Within the spring of 1899, George Smith grew to become the third of John and Joann’s sons to relocate to America. After beginning out in Chicago as an assistant to Willie at Midlothian, George went west the next 12 months to work as knowledgeable on the San Rafael Nation Membership in California. And that fall, Willie captured the U.S. Open on the Baltimore Nation Membership by a document 11 strokes, a margin of victory not damaged till Tiger Woods took the 2000 U.S. Open at Pebble Seashore by 15 pictures.
Clearly, the Smith brothers had settled fairly comfortably into life within the New World, and 9 years after Willie’s triumph in Baltimore, they’d be joined by their youngest sibling, Macdonald. Simply 18 years previous on the time, he would go on to win 25 PGA Tour occasions.
Mackesey says that Macdonald was pretty much as good as any aggressive golfer within the States after he arrived. However he was by no means capable of seize America’s nationwide open, although he got here achingly shut in 1910 when he was runner-up in that match to brother Alex after shedding to him and American John McDermott in a playoff. Twenty years later, Macdonald completed second in each the U.S. Open and Open Championship to Bobby Jones throughout the Georgian’s historic Grand Slam run.
In between these near-misses got here maybe probably the most painful lack of all, within the 1925 Open Championship, which was the final one ever performed at Prestwick.
The pre-tournament favourite, Macdonald held a five-stroke lead when he teed off within the ultimate spherical. However the golfer staggered dwelling with an 82 that left him in fourth place.
In his seminal e-book on the golf career, “Medical doctors of the Recreation,” PGA of America grasp skilled Billy Dettlaff describes the gallery that day as “unmanageable,” with spectators crowding round Smith so carefully that he couldn’t put a correct swing on most pictures and even see the fairways and greens in entrance of him. Some within the gallery had been accused of kicking his balls out of excellent positions into unhealthy lies to make sure that Macdonald didn’t win – and that they gained the bets they’d made in opposition to him.
Sadly, these disappointments overshadowed Macdonald’s general enjoying document, which included three Western Opens titles (in 1912, 1925 and 1933) and an equal variety of triumphs within the Metropolitan Open (in 1914, 1926 and 1931).
And in 1924, Macdonald completed fourth within the U.S. Open and third within the Open Championship again dwelling.
Macdonald’s enjoying document was however one factor that set him aside. He additionally loved a stellar profession as a membership skilled, holding the pinnacle professional job at Oakmont outdoors Pittsburgh and serving as an assistant to his brother Alex at Wykagyl in New Rochelle, New York. Macdonald was additionally a pioneer in California golf, working at Diablo Nation Membership and Claremont Nation Membership within the San Francisco Bay Space, Oakmont Nation Membership close to Los Angeles and the Del Monte Golf Course on the Monterey Peninsula.
It was throughout his time within the Golden State that Macdonald acted as swing physician to Jack Neville, who captured the primary of his 5 California State Beginner championships in 1912 and went on to signify the US within the 1923 Walker Cup.
To make certain, these jobs solely moved Smith farther away from Carnoustie. However he felt fairly at dwelling within the West, particularly provided that his father, mom and brother James had settled within the Bay Space, along with his father and James taking jobs at Diablo as effectively. Macdonald additionally labored as George’s assistant at Claremont and Del Monte.
Pretty much as good a aggressive golfer as Mac was, brother Alex was even higher. His two U.S. Open titles, in 1906 and 1910, converse to that. So do the 11 top-10 finishes he recorded in 18 appearances in that championship. And people embrace being runner-up 3 times. Smith additionally took a pair of Western Open titles and 4 Met Opens.
However as was the case with brother Macdonald, Alex Smith stood out in different areas of the sport throughout the 32 years he spent within the States. As a membership skilled, he held the pinnacle positions at a few of America’s finest golf equipment, amongst them Nassau Nation Membership on Lengthy Island, Westchester Nation Membership outdoors New York Metropolis and the Atlanta Athletic Membership, the place he was the primary professional. Alex additionally helped carry the sport to such outposts as Southern California (Coronado) and Florida, the place he served as the pinnacle golf skilled for 20 winters on the Belleair Nation Membership outdoors Tampa earlier than serving to hotelier John McEntee Bowman set up the Miami Biltmore.
As well as, Alex acted as a mentor to most of the immigrant professionals who traveled from the previous nation to the U.S. for work, offering the identical help and steering that Bob Simpson gave him as a teenager in Carnoustie.
Alex was additionally a lot in demand in America as a instructor and counted as his pupils Jerome Travers, who along with his 4 U.S. Beginner triumphs captured the 1915 U.S. Open, and Glenna Collett Vare, the winner of six U.S. Ladies’s Amateurs. Not surprisingly given their data, each these golfers ended up within the World Golf Corridor of Fame, as did one other pupil of his, Marion Hollins.
Willie Smith had a a lot much less peripatetic profession as a golf skilled, spending most of his time within the States operating the golf program at Midlothian after a one-year stint at Shinnecock. However he had maybe probably the most colourful one of many clan after shifting south of the border in 1904 to take the pinnacle professional job on the Mexico Metropolis Nation Membership. Two years after that, Willie gained the Mexico Open. However he continued to play in main championships, even returning to Scotland in 1910 for that 12 months’s Open Championship at St. Andrews, ending fifth after holding the 36-hole lead.
Issues in Mexico received somewhat dicey with the beginning of the Mexican Revolution in 1910. At one level throughout that battle, which continued by the last decade, the membership was occupied by troops related to the revolutionary Emiliano Zapata, as they noticed it as a logo of the corrupt ruling class. The rebels used the ballroom as a secure for his or her horses and stole no matter garments the members had of their lockers.
The membership remained within the crossfire for a number of years and was even shelled now and again. Decided to guard the property, Smith refused to depart. Newspaper accounts reveal that in one artillery barrage, Smith hid within the cellar of the clubhouse, solely to change into pinned underneath a beam that had collapsed throughout the preventing.
Whereas he survived that assault, the continuing stress of the battle took its toll, with Willie Smith dying the day after Christmas 1916, on the age of 40. Whereas his physique was interred in Mexico Metropolis, his brothers positioned a gravestone for him within the household plot again dwelling.
That appeared an comprehensible transfer, for his or her dwelling village meant the world to the Smith brothers. It could not have possessed the colour and character of St. Andrews. Nevertheless it had its golf. And the game gave these brothers and lots of different native sons an avenue out of the jute mills and an opportunity to do one thing they honestly liked. It was additionally a option to distinguish themselves, they usually did that largely by serving to a complete nation fall in love with the sport on the flip of the twentieth century.
The Smiths actually stood out. However others from Carnoustie made important contributions to the expansion of golf in America as effectively. Akin to Alex’s brothers-in-law, Stewart and Jimmy Maiden, each of whom labored at East Lake Golf Membership in Atlanta. Jimmy is credited with serving to a younger Bobby Jones get his begin in golf, whereas Stewart served as Jones’ swing coach in later years. And it was Jimmy who gave Jones his well-known Calamity Jane putter, which he used to win 10 majors from 1926 to his Grand Slam 12 months of 1930.
One other native son of be aware was George Low Sr., who made his option to America after studying methods to make golf golf equipment from Archie Simpson. He labored for some 25 years because the course superintendent and head skilled on the Baltusrol Golf Membership in New Jersey.
“They left dwelling to make a dwelling, with desires of glory,” says Mackesey. “However like good ambassadors, they by no means forgot the place they got here from.”
These are all issues value contemplating for anybody who visits Carnoustie and walks previous Robert Simpson’s golf store, which continues to be in enterprise (although not family-owned) and the place his grandson, a Grateful Lifeless-loving octogenarian named Trevor Williamson, stops by to speak with prospects. And by the clubhouse on the Carnoustie Golf Membership, the place Alex, Willie and Macdonald all gained membership championships (and the place the medals and trophies they gained of their aggressive careers are displayed).
Additionally it is value standing for a spell by the 18th inexperienced of the Championship Course, a simple pitch shot from each buildings, and suppose not solely of the golfers who’ve gained and misplaced Open Championships on that floor but additionally the individuals who grew up enjoying there and all they gave golf after bravely crusing to the New World.
There may be nothing nasty about that.
Prime photograph: Macdonald Smith throughout the 1925 Open Championship (Kirby/Topical Press Company, Getty Photographs)
© 2025 World Golf Put up LLC
