Kyle Tucker, Cody Bellinger, Bo Bichette, or Alex Bregman, who’s the perfect match?

They’ve added beginning pitchers, they’ve added reduction choices, and so they’ve added an fascinating bat, however they nonetheless haven’t changed Bo Bichette. Final season, the free agent slashed .311/.357/.483 with 18 residence runs in 628 plate appearances for a 134 wRC+. It was an awesome rebound season after a disastrous 2024.

Kyle Tucker

Tucker is the perfect bat in the marketplace, however he additionally suits what the Blue Jays love in a participant. He’s a contact hitter who hardly ever strikes out, can hit for energy, and is strong defensively. The outfielder can also be one thing that they want, provided that he’s a left-handed batting outfielder who has hit second within the lineup all through his profession.

Final season, Tucker slashed .266/.377/.464 with 22 residence runs in 597 plate appearances. It’s been reported that the outfielder suffered a hairline fracture on his hand, which may clarify his “down yr”. Previous to the hand harm that was sustained on Jun. 1, Tucker slashing .283/.391/.520 with 12 residence runs in 266 plate appearances, ok for a 150 wRC+

Even after the harm, Tucker slashed .253/.366/.419 with 10 residence runs in 331 plate appearances, as he had a 125 wRC+ in that span. Tucker is a authentic gamechanger, his 23.4 fWAR since 2021 is the Tenth-best for place gamers.

He’s the kind of participant {that a} contender indicators, even when he isn’t a match. It simply so occurs that Tucker is a match for the Blue Jays.

Cody Bellinger

Final season with the New York Yankees, Bellinger slashed .272/.334/.480 with 29 residence runs in 656 plate appearances, with an 8.7 BB% and 13.7 Ok% for a 125 wRC+. He avoids hanging out, makes strong contact, and is an efficient defensive fielder in each the outfield and at first base, so why is Tucker the far superior participant regardless of the value level?

Properly, Bellinger, a left-handed bat, benefited from taking part in at Yankee Stadium for half his video games. Bellinger additionally tends to chase exterior the zone fairly a bit, however avoids whiffing. He’s not a nasty second choice if the Blue Jays really need a left-handed batting outfield, however Tucker ought to be their precedence.

Bo Bichette

The match with Bichette is a bit more difficult with the signing of Okamoto, however the Jays can nonetheless make it work. On this case, Ernie Clement would slide to an excellent utility function, whereas Addison Barger would play proper area.

Though he’s not the perfect match, nor the perfect bat in the marketplace, Bichette has spent his whole skilled profession with the Jays and has performed alongside Vladimir Guerrero Jr. primarily each step of the best way. Bichette has stated loads of occasions he desires to win with Guerrero Jr., so you must think about he has curiosity in returning, even when there seems to be mutual curiosity with the Phillies.

By way of what Bichette presents with the bat, he’s completely a match. He’s among the finest contact hitters within the sport, main Main League Baseball in hits in each 191 and 189, and almost doing so in 2025 regardless of lacking the final three weeks.

Final season proved that his poor 2024 was only a blip, however there’s authentic concern about his defence at shortstop, his previous accidents, and declining pace.

Alex Bregman

Bregman is just like each Bellinger and myself, as his greatest yr was in 2019. That season, Bregman slashed .296/.423/.592 with 41 residence runs in 690 plate appearances. He hasn’t reached these heights since, however he’s the kind of participant who’ll provide you with round 25 residence runs a season, along with his 18 residence runs in 2025 being an exception.

Like the opposite three gamers talked about on this article, Bregman is a robust contact hitter who hardly ever strikes out, with the added bonus of having the ability to draw loads of walks. Sadly, he simply isn’t a lot of a match anymore with the signing of Okamoto.